From the moment this project was announced, I knew it wasn’t a good idea. Remaking Broadchurch for an American audience, with the same star, mere months after the original had aired on BBC America, seemed like a pointless exercise when it was announced last May and, based, on the results FOX saw in the fall, it certainly turned out to be just that.
David Tennant returned as the lead detective and gave basically the same performance, except for swapping in an American accent. That’s not to say that it wasn’t a good performance, just that it was the same. Which is my main complaint about Gracepoint: it was the same. Why bother remaking anything (a show, movie, or even song) if you are only going to replicate what came before. From my recollection, there was a minor difference in the ending, which seems to be tacked on not for any creative reasons, but simply to fulfill the promise that the ending would be different for those that had already seen Broadchurch.
Series 2 of Broadchurch aired on BBC America earlier this year, but FOX has decided to not move forward with replicating it for a second seaon of Gracepoint. But before you start to think that the network has learned anything from this experience, they have ordered an American remake of the BBC show Luther, which starred Idris Elba.
