Nearly 4 years ago, we first counted down the Top 200 albums in my iTunes library. Since that time, I’ve successfully managed to migrate my music collection to a new PC with the stats intact. So, I figured it was time to take another look, based on number of plays from late 2007 through January 1, 2018.

We continue with the next batch of 10 albums ranked between #31 and 40, including 3 studio recordings, 3 greatest hits packages, and 1 live performance.

#40: Patton Oswalt – Finest Hour
iTunes stats: 128 plays
Previous Ranking: N/A

The fourth album from the mind of Patton Oswalt makes an impressive debut on the list.

#39: Garfunkel and Oates – Music Songs
iTunes stats: 129 plays
Previous Ranking: 36

8 tracks from the musical comedy duo of Riki Lindhome and Kate Micucci make up this total.

#38: David Cross – Shut Up, You Fucking Baby!
iTunes stats: 130 plays
Previous Ranking: 54

Every track from the first comedy album from David Cross makes up this total.

#37: Garbage – Garbage
iTunes stats: 132 plays
Previous Ranking: 54

The debut album from the Garbagers, whose total would be higher if not for their greatest hits album, makes the list on the backs of 12 tunes.

#36: Motley Crue – Motley Crue Greatest Hits
iTunes stats: 133 plays
Previous Ranking: 29

9 of the glam metal bands biggest hits make up the total for this greatest hits package.

#35: Alanis Morissette – Jagged Little Pill
iTunes stats: 137 plays
Previous Ranking: 37

The smash American debut album from the Canadian songstress had 13 tracks make up this total.

#34: Journey – Journey’s Greatest Hits
iTunes stats: 138 plays
Previous Ranking: 14

4 different tunes make up this total, although 1 of them contributes the vast majority of the listens thanks to its links to the 2005 World Series champions.

#33: Tom Petty & The Heartbreakers – Greatest Hits
iTunes stats: 139 plays
Previous Ranking: 48

10 of Tom Petty’s biggest hits make up the total for this greatest hits compilation.

#32: Garbage – Chicago ’05
iTunes stats: 149 plays
Previous Ranking: 29

This bootleg, from the bands 2005 show at the Metro, uses all 17 songs from its setlist to make up this total.

#31: Garbage – Version 2.0
iTunes stats: 152 plays
Previous Ranking: 34

12 tracks from the band’s second album make up this total.