3 years ago, we first counted down the then Top 100 songs in my iTunes library. Since that time, I’ve successfully managed to migrate my music collection to a new PC with the stats intact. So, I figured it was time to take another look, expanding out the field to the top 200 songs, based on number of plays as of January 1, 2016.

Today, we break into the first grouping of songs tied for 118th place with 19 plays apiece since late 2007.

#118: Toad The Wet Sprocket – Something’s Always Wrong
iTunes stats: 19 plays, most recently on 7/20/2015
Previous ranking: Unranked

The second single from the band’s fourth album reached #9 on the Billboard modern rock charts.

#118: Tegan and Sara – I Bet It Stung
iTunes stats: 19 plays, most recently on 7/21/2015
Previous ranking: Unranked

An album track from Tegan and Sara’s fourth studio album.

#118: Mark Snow – X-Files Theme
iTunes stats: 19 plays, most recently on 12/18/2015
Previous ranking: Unranked

The theme song from the long-running sci-fi hit on FOX.

#118: Lustra – Scotty Doesn’t Know
iTunes stats: 19 plays, most recently on 8/20/2015
Previous ranking: Unranked

The main song from the film Eurotrip, explaining how poor Scotty doesn’t know his girlfriend is cheating on him.

#118: Less Than Jake – I Think I Love You
iTunes stats: 19 plays, most recently on 7/21/2015
Previous ranking: #96

This cover of the Partridge Family hit was featured on the Scream 2 soundtrack.

#118: The Knack – My Sharona
iTunes stats: 19 plays, most recently on 12/4/2014
Previous ranking: Unranked

The debut single from The Knack, which spent 6 weeks at #1 on the Hot 100 chart and ended up as the #1 single of 1979.

#118: Garfunkel and Oates – The Ex-Boyfriend Song
iTunes stats: 19 plays, most recently on 9/7/2015
Previous ranking: Unranked

A brief repose from the musical comedy duo.

#118: Foo Fighters – All My Life
iTunes stats: 19 plays, most recently on 9/7/2015
Previous ranking: Unranked

This first single from band’s fourth album earned them a Grammy for best hard rock performance.

#118: Foo Fighters – Best Of You
iTunes stats: 19 plays, most recently on 3/7/2015
Previous ranking: Unranked

This first single from band’s fifth album earned them a Grammy nomination for best rock song.

#118: Foo Fighters – This Is A Call
iTunes stats: 19 plays, most recently on 9/2/2015
Previous ranking: Unranked

This first single from band’s first album was one of the few written after the death of Dave Grohl’s old bandmate Kurt Cobain.